Friday, May 17, 2013

Of shattered hopes and renewed expectations

white paper

Dear outgoing government people,

Hello, and congratulations on completing your five year tenure as the Government of Pakistan. It isn’t clear whether one should be impressed or appalled by the fact that you guys are the first Pakistani government to ever do so. At any rate, I would like to tell you that you did a great job running this country. Well, I WOULD like to tell you that, but I can’t because I’m quite fond of the current size of my nose and don’t particularly want it to become longer; it just wouldn’t suit me is all.

At any rate, you are now a part of the history of this country, and will forever remain so, no matter how much some of us may wish that we could, well, wish you away. Wouldn’t it be something if we could just collectively wake up from the nightmare that has been the last decade and find ourselves in a country that is peaceful, prosperous, and actually has electricity for more than half the day?

Speaking of which … what exactly DID your administration have against electricity? The reasons for your deep-rooted hatred for power generation never became fully apparent to me. What was up with the whole no power for 12 or 15 or 18 hours a day thing? Was it the misappropriation of funds, the lack of power plants, the unavailability of natural gas, or just plain misadministration? Or were you simply trying to make us more grateful for what we have, as we yearned for the good old times when there was only 6 hours of load shedding per day, while teaching us endurance and patience? In which case, touché! Lesson learned.

Before we go any further, I would like to clarify that I do fully appreciate the efforts that you did make to turn Pakistan into an even better country. For instance, who can forget your response to that marathon bombing after which you guys brought the whole city to a standstill while you quickly identified the two suspects, combed the entire area for these men, and didn’t rest until you found both culprits, and … oh wait, that was America. Sorry, my bad. I'm sure you would have done something about the bombings and shooting too had they not turned into white noise over the years. But hey, you did make the valiant effort of turning off our mobile phones, so who can say you guys weren’t as dynamic and effective as the American forces?

While with the Americans, it was an unforgettable highlight of your regime when the U.S. Navy SEALS violated our sovereignty to carry out a covert operation in Abbottabad and assassinate the most wanted man in the universe, he who must not be named. It’s hard to decide whether his presence in this country or the U.S. operation, right under your noses yet without your knowledge, was more shocking. Or maybe it was your inability to stop the U.S. drone attacks in our north western regions? How about I leave it up to you? You can let me know what you found most appalling. Send me a tweet when you figure it out.

I’d say leave a message on my YouTube video wherein I read this letter to you, but you have very astutely made that impossible. I applaud your decision to block an entire portal that hosts millions of useful, educational, and entertaining clips because of one man’s display of stupidity and insensitivity, instead of only blocking that depraved piece of work. That’s just the kind of smart and intelligent administration that you were. Letting one degenerate disrupt something for millions of people is always the right way to go.

As we part, I would like to thank you for being coerced into holding elections this May. Leaving just might be the best thing you did for this country. You will forever have our gratitude for it. Now let’s see if you have brought this country to the point where we think your best replacement is an ex cricket player, or if we still need more lessons in patience and endurance and therefore opt to go for five more years under the likes of you.

Oh and thanks for the inflation too. We would have had no idea what to do with all our money without your help, so muchos gracias for making sure that all of it goes towards feeding our families and putting food on the table. If we’re lucky enough, that is. And my commiserations to you for the Supreme Court’s efforts to thwart your attempts of becoming the richest people in Switzerland. Maybe next time.

Despairingly yours,

A citizen who may or may not be a teeny tiny little bit disgruntled

*****

Dear new government folk,

Hello, and congratulations on winning the elections. It brings me great joy to see you in power, because now you will improve the education system, help business flourish, eradicate poverty, fix the energy crisis, and bring peace to this country, just as you promised. I, of course, believe all your promises. Partly because no matter how hard you and your predecessors have tried, I still carry the hope in my heart that someday someone will prove that the term “honest politician” isn’t an oxymoron. And partly because I’m a gullible idiot. Well, mostly because I’m a gullible idiot.

Which makes what I’m about to say all the more important: for the love of what’s left of my sanity (and you can very clearly see that not much remains), please do something about the load shedding. I am not so much close to losing my marbles as I am to taking all my marbles and then smashing them to smithereens with a giant hammer. Yes, we are a resilient people, but that doesn’t mean you have to take our resilience as a challenge. Give us a break. And don’t, for the second time in a row, make us regret our collective democratic choice.

Democracy, as we’ve seen in the last few weeks, is a peculiar thing. First we watch you all sling mud at each other for a while; then – after all your faults and flaws have been thoroughly highlighted – anoint one of you as our leader; and then wonder why things aren’t getting better for our country. A tongue in cheek political ideology suggests that anyone who wants to be a politician shouldn’t be allowed to be one, and the last few years add credence to this claim. Despite all that, there’s a sense of empowerment and exhilaration that comes with the electoral process, one that isn’t diminished by the fact that we have to choose between less than ideal options. Ultimately, and perhaps in a triumph of hope over experience, it is still good to see that we have now elected you as our new government and done so despite the many uncertainties that surrounded the process.

Once again, a most hearty hurrah to you on making the utterly splendid decision of opting to take the reins of a country that is about as stable as francium. By some celestial miracle, be different and be better. Be the anomaly. Be the change we yearn for and deserve. As they say, third time’s the charm.

May the force be with you. Heaven knows you’ll need it.

Skeptically yours,

A disgruntled citizen who is trying really hard to fake optimism

- S.A.

Us Magazine, The News - 17th May, 2013

Sunday, May 12, 2013

Oblivion

movie review: in the picture

Oblivion **1/2

Starring: Tom Cruise, Andrea Riseborough, Olga Kurylenko, Melissa Leo, Morgan Freeman, Nikolaj Coster-Waldau
Director: Joseph Kosinski
Tagline: Earth is a memory worth fighting for.

So you think Hollywood lacks originality? Well, good news: Oblivion proves your point! A hodgepodge of ideas from science fiction past, the film borrows heavily from the far superior movies that have preceded it to create a special effects laden collage of familiar bits and pieces.

Derivate to its core, Oblivion takes us to post apocalyptic Earth, where an attack by aliens called Scavengers (or Scavs) has turned the world into an uninhabitable wasteland. It is year 2077, and the surviving humans have been whisked away to a colony on Saturn's moon Titan. Technician Jack Harper (Tom Cruise) and his “effective” partner Victoria (Andrea Riseborough) are still stationed on Earth to secure the remaining resources and repair the drones that are overseeing this mission and fending off the Scavs.

Things, however, start to unravel with the arrival of Julia (Olga Kurylenko), a mysterious occupant of a crashed spaceship, who has haunted Jack's visions prior to her appearance. A series of events - not necessarily predictable, but very comprehensively unoriginal - lead Jack to question his mission. Then Morgan Freeman shows up, as he often does, to tell us what is really going on.

With not a single original bone in its oversized body, the film comes off as an unevenly paced dystopian drama which occasionally gives way to some frantically convoluted action. The initial setup feels all too familiar; think WALL-E, minus its irresistible charm and joy. It then turns into a game of 'guess the inspiration' as Oblivion trudges from plot points of one sci-fi classic to another. Its derivativeness might not have been such a massive problem had it not been so obvious and the borrowed points had been concealed under a layer of creativity. Creativity, however, rarely makes an appearance in this film.

A better script would certainly have helped. Oblivion's overreliance on voiceover narration, with Tom Cruise walking us through the story, acts in its detriment; it would have been more interesting had they let us discover things on our own and made the reveals more nuanced. While Cruise does put in a considerable effort to bring Jack to life, his generic action hero character could have done with a more distinctive personality, and the icy Victoria and the vacant Julia could have used more substance that would have turned them into better defined and more engaging characters.

Where the films impresses, though, is in its looks and design. The sleek visuals, the effective use of whites and grays, and the futuristic aesthetics make Oblivion's world striking. It is this aspect of the film that appears to have been crafted with artistic attention and care. The action itself is also well executed. And M83's score works overtime to make up for the lack of tension in the script. But without much heart underneath, these glossy embellishments can't help but feel hollow and squandered.

Oblivion's style over substance approach shows yet again that, as with Tron Legacy, Joseph Kosinski is more effective at creating visuals than characters. Had he paid more attention to the story and screenplay and relied less on borrowed elements, he could have created a much more effective science fiction tapestry. As it stands, the movie's intentions seem transparently commercial, and it is unlikely to satisfy sci-fi devotees. The film may want to leave the viewer with existential quandaries, but doesn't pull this off nearly as convincingly as the many films it blatantly rips off. Oblivion does have the ability to keep you watching and trying to figure out what's going on, and you won't want to abandon the film midway, but its story could have been a lot more interesting if Kosinski had come up with something more unique and creative, and made the characters more warm and the proceedings easier to invest into.

– Sameen Amer

Instep, The News on Sunday - 12th May, 2013

Sunday, May 05, 2013

No love for Paramore

album review 

Since the band lost two of their band members, Paramore have yet to find the sound which brought them their initial fame 

Band: Paramore
Album: Paramore

Towards the end of 2010, pop rock band Paramore found themselves in turmoil. An acrimonious split with the band's co-founders - guitarist and lyricist Josh Farro and drummer Zac Farro - left the group down to three members amidst a very public squabble. The brothers claimed that the band had “somehow morphed into a manufactured product of a major label,” turning into a showcase for vocalist Hayley Williams while relegating the others to the background.

Now, nearly two and a half years on, the remaining members of the band return with their first album since the split and do little to dissuade the Farros' claims.

With 17 tracks running over an hour in length, the group's self-titled fourth album sees the remaining trio - singer Hayley Williams, bassist Jeremy Davis, and guitarist Taylor York - soldier on with the help of Lostprophets and Nine Inch Nails drummer Ilan Rubin, who has been recruited to record the drums for this set. Producer Justin Meldal-Johnsen helms the project and brings electronic influences with him that are sprinkled throughout the record.

Wrapped in tight hooks and infectious melodies, the eponymous album re-attests to the fact that despite their attitude, Paramore really are a pop band at heart. Taking a step away from their diluted punk sound and incorporating more synth and electronica into their music, Paramore have created their most diverse album to date. From the gospel choir on the soul influenced 'Ain't It Fun' to the three ukulele driven interludes, the group tries different things on these tracks, adding whatever embellishments strike their whims. The results offer variety, but never present a cohesive picture of the group.

Experimentation is a commendable thing, and the band deserves props for expanding their musical palette, but going off in every direction at the same time doesn't result in the most self-assured project, and that is the predicament that befalls Paramore. Put together, the album feels like it's all over the place and suggests a band that is trying too hard and is uncertain of their identity and unfocused in their experimentation. Even with the supposed adventurous overtures, the record still slants towards a more pop-oriented and mainstream sound instead of going for touches that are more unique and innovative. Also, the album comes off as a little overlong; it might have helped if Paramore had left out some filler and gone for a shorter, more consistent set.

The lyrical content too isn't a particularly impressive element of the record. The lyrics could use fine-tuning and have a long way to go as far as maturity is concerned. Whether it's the clichéd ballads or the up-tempo romps, the words here aren't exactly the most striking and memorable part of these songs. Plus the group's decision to make what appear to be veiled (or perhaps even direct) references to their issues with and feelings towards the Farros isn't the most respectable way to go. Dissing your former bandmates (on songs like 'Interlude: Moving On' in which Hayley sings “let 'em spill their guts, 'cause one day they're gonna slip on 'em” and “let 'em play their songs, let 'em say what's right and wrong”) is just as charming as Taylor Swift droning on about her exes.

Overall, Paramore is an ambitious but overlong pop record that is playful and catchy, but offers less punk rock and displays more mainstream tendencies. The results often sound like a cross between Taylor Swift and Gwen Stefani/No Doubt, and are likely to appeal to the same demographic. The new set might split fans, although there is something here for (almost) everyone; longtime fans are likely to appreciate songs like 'Proof', while mainstream listeners will enjoy the straightforward pop of tracks like 'Still Into You'. Those who thought of Paramore as nothing more than glorified bubblegum pop aren't likely to be impressed by this record, although they could possibly find a song or two here that they might enjoy. Hopefully this album will help Paramore figure out who they really are and decide which direction they want to take so that they can hone their creative energy and make the solid pop record that this one hints towards.

- By Sameen Amer

Instep, The News on Sunday - 5th May, 2013

The Office star Mindy Kaling tells it like it is

book review

TV actress, writer, director, and author Mindy Kaling shares zany insight in her book

Author: Mindy Kaling
Book: Is Everyone Hanging Out Without Me? (And Other Concerns)

Mindy Kaling first came to prominence as a staff writer and actor (portraying the character of Kelly Kapoor) on the U.S. version of The Office, and has since spearheaded her own sitcom, The Mindy Project. In between, the American comedian also scribed a book called, Is Everyone Hanging Out Without Me? (And Other Concerns), a collection of essays, anecdotes, and recollections.

Offering an amusing take on her life, work, and other experiences, the book sees the author talk about her childhood, being chubby, getting bullied by a Senegalese kid, her best friends, living in New York, the success of Matt & Ben, her career in television, being a part of The Office, romance, her appearance, and her legacy. Along the way, Mindy comes up with various lists on topics like the exact level of fame she wants, the rights and responsibilities of best friends, the types of women in romantic comedy who are not real, franchises she would like to reboot, and her favourite moments in comedy.

As far as its content goes, Is Everyone Hanging Out Without Me? is noticeably thin. The writer simply does not have enough substance to produce a solid book, and based on the content, doesn't appear to have amassed enough life experience to come up with a full length tome. Some of the lists work, others don't, but when she gets to the point where she has to do things like share narcissistic photos from her Blackberry, you can clearly tell that she has really run out of things to write about. The book is at its most interesting when Mindy is talking about her life and experiences; the unnecessary asides feel distracting and pointless and are not nearly as clever as the writer might have hoped. Perhaps Mindy could have written a more substantial book, had she waited a few more years and had more and better stories to tell her readers.

It also does not help that the text misses a sense of direction and cohesion. The writer meanders through different topics, seemingly at random, without fully detailing most of them. Many ideas are touched upon but not fully explored. As a result, the prose feels unfocused, directionless, and lacking depth; the prose itself isn't a strength either. The tone is fairly engaging, albeit overly snarky, but the style seems closer to that of a blog than a book. It's the kind of writing style where the writer frequently ends sentences with phrases like “or something”, “or anything”, and “or whatever”. The humour is blunt and abrasive, and while Is Everyone Hanging Out Without Me? is mildly amusing, it rarely goes beyond being just that. For someone whose actual job is as a comedy writer, the chapters offered here aren't as funny or smooth as one would hope; you can easily find funnier and more insightful pieces on a number of blogs online.

Then again, all of that might not be a problem for many readers, because the book appears to be directed towards a certain segment, and simply isn't meant for the rest of us. The content will probably connect more with younger, especially female, readers. It will also give The Office fans a behind-the-scene glimpse of the show. Reading the tome is like spending time with a girly, overly talkative friend who jabbers on about anything that comes to her mind while trying a little too hard to be edgy. The author did not sit down to paint a clear picture of her life but just wanted to offer random nuggets of her experiences and thoughts in a friendly, informal way, and in that she has succeeded.

For the most part, Is Everyone Hanging Out Without Me? reads more like a blog, and not a particularly well-written or interesting one. This isn't intelligent comedy that will blow you away. Sure the book is funny, but varyingly so. While Mindy may have accomplished a lot, she is unable to translate that into the book or make her story very compelling. That is why Is Everyone Hanging Out Without Me? seems insubstantial, unfocused, and padded, although none of that stops the book from being amusing and fun.

- By Sameen Amer

Instep, The News on Sunday - 5th May, 2013

Sunday, April 28, 2013

Jack the Giant Slayer

movie review: in the picture

Jack the Giant Slayer **1/2

Starring: Nicholas Hoult, Eleanor Tomlinson, Stanley Tucci, Ian McShane, Bill Nighy, and Ewan McGregor
Director: Bryan Singer
Tagline: Prepare for a giant adventure

Riding on the fantasy adventure wave driven by the current trend of live action fairytale retellings, Bryan Singer's Jack the Giant Slayer offers a spruced up mash-up of the Jack the Giant Killer and Jack and the Beanstalk stories.

Drenched in CGI and slathered with special effects, the film follows the story of Jack (Nicholas Hoult), an orphaned farmhand who comes in possession of some magic beans. A series of events results in one of those beans taking root, lifting Jack's house and its unlikely occupant, the headstrong Princess Isabelle (Eleanor Tomlinson), up into the sky, thrusting them into the realm of grotesque giants, led by the two-headed Fallon (Bill Nighy and John Kassir). To save his daughter and kingdom, King Brahmwell (Ian McShane) puts together a royal search party, which includes the heroic knight Elmont (Ewan McGregor), the King's duplicitous advisor and Isabelle's fiancé (albeit against her choice) Roderick (Stanley Tucci), Roderick's attendant Wicke (Ewan Bremner), and of course Jack. They must go up the beanstalk, battle the giants, rescue Isabelle, and defend the Kingdom of Cloister, while the treacherous Roderick tries to enslave the giants, attack the kingdom, and usurp power.

Its star-studded cast is the film's biggest asset. He may not necessarily seem like the most ideal choice for the part, but the talented Nicholas Hoult makes a likeable (although perhaps a little too dreamy eyed) hero. The ever dependable Ewan McGregor and Stanley Tucci give solid performances. And it helps that the giants are given their own internal dynamics instead of presenting them as homogenous cardboard cutouts. But ever so often, the focus seems to be excessively on the action and special effects instead of on the characters. Isabelle's character, for instance, is too stereotypical and isn't presented in the most compelling way, and her romance with Jack is more yawn-inducing than exciting.

The adequate script and satisfying pace help to build some tension even though we pretty much know where the story is heading. It is the film's predictability, though, that drags it down and keeps it from being a fully engrossing experience. With stylistic elements that seem indebted to films like The Princess Bride and The Lord of the Rings, the movie owes many of its features to the classics that preceded it, and doesn't seem at all concerned with even attempting to give the semblance of putting an original spin on its borrowed styles. Combine that with hackneyed plot points, unimaginative relationships, and strict adherence to the genre's predefined pattern, and you're left with a film that feels generic and trite.

Overall, Jack the Giant Slayer is neither a wreck, nor a masterpiece. It is a functional adaptation of an old tale with surfeit action - the proceedings are too violent for very young viewers, and many of the intense and gruesome scenes might scare children - that sticks to the fantasy adventure template and takes us to a familiar territory that we've visited many times before. At no point during its 114 minute runtime does it become clear why someone thought it was a good idea to dole out a whooping $195 million on this project. Ultimately Jack the Giant Slayer is fun but predictable and weighed down by its clichés and lack of originality. It definitely isn't essential viewing, but it can be sporadically entertaining, especially if you go in with low expectations.

– Sameen Amer

Instep, The News on Sunday - 28th April, 2013

Sunday, April 21, 2013

The Strokes: greater than the sum of their parts

album review

Band: The Strokes
Album: Comedown Machine

Releasing a brilliant album that is hailed as one of the best records of its decade is obviously a massive triumph, but it can also be a bit of a curse. Sure it portrays the artists' talents and proves their musical abilities, but it also leaves them with a slight problem: everything they do from that point on for the rest of their career gets compared to the awesomeness of that massive release, leaving them straining under the weight of their own success.

The Strokes are a prime example of this phenomenon. The rock band's critically acclaimed debut album Is This It was lauded for its raw energy and infectious tunes, and celebrated for the impact it had on the alternative and indie scenes. However, everything they have released since, no matter how good it has been, ends up being evaluated in Is This It's shadow, a comparison that is both tiring and unfair.

To their credit though (and despite whatever frayed internal dynamics they have had to endure over the years), the band doesn't seem to have collapsed under the weight of struggling to match or top their hit album, and has (very wisely) not spent the rest of their career trying to replicate their definitive record. And on their new release, the group members prove that they may have sonically moved on, but they haven't completely lost themselves in the process.

On Comedown Machine, the rockers from New York retain their garage rock flavors while offering some '80s pastiche, weaving new wave and synth pop into their sound. The group's fifth studio release sees them carry on in the direction they took on their previous album, 2011's Angles. The new set feels like a logical follow-up to its predecessor, and also exhibits sonic similarities to Julian Casablancas' solo effort, Phrazes for the Young (2009).

The group's instrumental talents are on display throughout the record. You can still find the vintage Strokes sound on this album on songs like the standout 'All the Time' and the brisk '50/50' which marries Nirvana's grunge with the Ramones' punk. Elsewhere, the synth grooves and throwback vibes take over on tracks like the a-ha reminiscent 'One Way Trigger', the funky 'Tap Out', and the groovy 'Welcome to Japan'. The Strokes make good use of their fondness for exploring different eras and then incorporating them into their own sound, resulting in a contemporary take on familiar vibes from the past. It might take a few listens to fully appreciate the album's many flavors, and opinions may vary about Julian Casablancas' falsetto, plus the slick production may leave you yearning for more edge, but the well-crafted melodies embedded in its track as well as the group's willingness to take chances ultimately make Comedown Machine quite intriguing.

The last decade has been quite a journey for The Strokes, and as Comedown Machine marks the end of their contract with RCA, it also leaves doubt over the group's future; whether they choose to march on or part ways remains to be seen. All we know for now is that their latest record may not be as punchy as their first one was, but it holds its own kind of charm. The Strokes have operated under the shadow of a genre defining record, but their subsequent output shows that they have chosen not to be the victims of their own success. And that is what makes their efforts across their discography immensely enjoyable and an absolute triumph.

- By Sameen Amer

Instep, The News on Sunday - 21st April, 2013

Friday, April 19, 2013

Amusing and appalling ... in equal measures

book review

Author: Richard Benson
Book: F in Exams: The Very Best Totally Wrong Test Answers

Exams can be frustrating, and often have a knack for flustering students into making silly mistakes, botching up questions that they would otherwise have been more than capable of answering. But sometimes there’s also another snag: what if you really don’t know the answer? What if, no matter how much you think, you simply draw a blank, and have no idea how to define the term, explain the concept, or solve the equation? If you’re anything like me, then you will still try your best to put something on the answer sheet that has even a remote chance of getting you some credit. But if you’re anything like the students in this book, then you will instead use this opportunity for something completely different: exercising your creativity and unleashing the comedian in you.

F in Exams: The Very Best Totally Wrong Test Answers is a collection of such amusing answers put together by Richard Benson. The book purports to offer “hilarious, real responses from students who realized that they had no hope of answering a question correctly, and decided to have a little fun instead.” The answers are arranged by subject (chemistry, biology, physics, math, business & technology, psychology, history & geography, and English). The material here ranges from witty and clever to simply unintelligent, and often seems to be amusing and appalling in equal measures. Here’s a taste of what the book has to offer:
Question: Steve is driving his car. He is traveling at 60 feet/second and the speed limit is 40 mph. Is Steve speeding?
Answer: He could find out by checking his speedometer.

Question: To change centimeters to meters, you _____.
Answer: Take out centi.

Question: Describe the term “stakeholder”.
Answer: A vampire hunter. Buffy being the most famous.

Question: What is a network?
Answer: When you chat to people you don’t like to try and get a job.

Question: Describe what is meant by forgetting.
Answer. I can’t remember.

Question: Name the successor of the first Roman emperor.
Answer: The second Roman emperor.

Amused? Then you will enjoy this book. Appalled? Then just wait till you read what else the students came up with.

The reaction F in Exams draws is decidedly mixed. For most students, grades aren’t a laughing matter; no one around me would have been amused if I didn’t even try to give proper answers and instead came up with smart alec-y responses, and I wouldn’t have been amused if my students did the same (and luckily, they never did). Which leads to an issue: are these answers even real? The book fails to mention its sources, doesn’t offer citations, and gives no explanation of the data collection methods. Sure it is meant to be entertaining, but is it really factual? Are these, in fact, real answers? If so, then how were they collected? Who were the students that came up with these amusing statements? And what were the teachers’ responses to them? Or did the author just come up with the answers himself? In which case, is the output amusing at all?

Overall, F in Exams is a (very) quick read – you will be done with the book in minutes – and its content varies from being witty to dim-witted; some responses are funny, others less so. And the validity of the “real” claim seems a little suspect, at least for some of the answers, a problem that could have been avoided by making use of a little transparency. Still, if you have ever wanted to scribble on your exam, sure that there’s no way to salvage the test and your grade, then you will relate to the predicament of these students, and if you need a small break from studying, then F in Exams will provide some laughs and a few moments of relief.

- S.A.

Us Magazine, The News - 18th April, 2013